Debate_Why_signed_up

= I invite you to take part in the debate. I read the article with so many adjectives and got confused. What about you? Why don't they use robots? =

=Donir=
 * = **FOR** ||= **AGAINST** ||
 * = =Dasha_O =

=IKermenka=

=Marina_Kh=

=Polina_E=

=Saga_T=

=Sanal E=

=Viktoria_G=

=Zayana_U= ||= =Delya_C = = = =GelaGelka=

=Kermen_U=

=Mariya_B=

=Saglara_G=

=Sanal_B=

=Vic_B=

=Zanda_K= =Elvira_G= || **PLEASE, EDIT CAREFULLY! I HAVE REVERTED THIS PAGE SO MANY TIMES! DON'T EDIT TWO AT A TIME, PLEEEEEAAASSSEEE!!!!!!!** To my mind, it’s a very good idea with these cute dogs, because it’s great that animals help us in such important matters. I think, that there is no difference between big and little dogs, because each has its ownadvantages. For example,“**//great value in search efforts//** **//in nooks of collapsed buildings only//** **//accessible to small, light creatures”//**. By and large I like this experience, because many dogs killed on the streets, no one needs, and may soon such cases will be a little. Saga_T
 * **FOR** || **AGAINST** ||

Ikermenka Toy-looking dogs! How sweet they are! And at the same time very helpful. According to the small size of Japan in general and consequences of such horrible disasters they are indispensable and irreplaceable! Only light and tiny creatures can have an access to all nooks in a collapsed building. So, to my mind, in this case these two lovely dogs are the best variant for the Japanese police. To keep such doggies is not so difficult and expensive, I mean the food. They might eat less than bigger dogs. They are a pocketsize, clever and smart way out of a problem of searching for people in destroyed buildings. Such a wise decision!

Sanal E

The work of police dogs is in many cases going not only about fighting against thieves and burglars but about finding drugs, weapons etc and they don’t need to be so powerful, moreover, it’s cheaper to held them, they are neater, the transportation is easier, they learn faster and make less harm to the environment.

Yes, they will not be able to stop the criminals directly using their teeth but… in Japan’s cities the police don’t it so much. They are also not so frightening for people around. They can squeeze the places where nobody is capable of penetrating inside.

Polina_E

To my mind this very idea is really good. Because poodles can be not only decorative dogs, but also making world be more safety, they do makesenseoflife. It is known that poodles can easily adapt toany climate. These small-breed dogs are very smart. And their dogs’ skill can be useful help to people in such contingency. And one more fact that I like, that Japanese invented this idea. I think that Japanese are very smart people. And what they invent it’s always has success.

I think that it’s a good idea to include a small breed of dogs into police force. Because if for example it’s necessary for policeman to find something, these small pretty dogs with their perfect smell ability can easily help them with their work. They can also indicate you a way, if you’ve been lost.(Marina)


 * Dasha_O **
 * I think that it will be a good experience. **
 * We shall see how small pretty dogs can be useful. **
 * Everybody get used that people have this small breed dogs **
 * only for beauty and amusement. **
 * But these small adorable dogs can also help a police. **
 * They are very nimble, high-spirited and fearless. **

I think it is remarkable idea. Poodles are very clever dogs and I think they can as well to serve in police as well as German shepherds. They can get into an accessible spots where the big dogs cannot get. (Viktoria_G)

Donir As for me, it’s a good idea to join the small dogs to the police prefectures, especially in Japan where there are so many earthquakes and floods. They will be extremely useful in finding people under the blockage of the broken buildings. Hope they will save many lives. || //Yes, good idea! But I do not think they can fight against // // drugs,crime and robbery ! For such work they need // // good police dogs such as Shepherds .// // Small poodles are not so dangerous! I do not think // // that it would be a barrier for robbers. Elvira_G//

GelaGelka This is ridiculous. If I were a robber or murderer and saw a policeman, who was to investigate my case, with such dog I would definitely laugh at him. It would be very funny for me to watch this cutie, trying to trace me. A policeman with a dog should frighten criminals and make citizens sure in safety. But Poodles... they are very nice and cute. And all you think of then is that you would like to play with it. And besides, this kind of a dog is too domestic. They are not to do any catch-people, find-drugs or run-fast activities. We should think about both: animals and peace. So, let German Shepherds take care of us and us to take care of poodles.

(corrected by Mariya_B)

I suppose that society will not take them seriously because they are small and not so strong. I’m sure that it will take much more time to train a small dog because they are …(Zanda)

(corrected by Mariya_B)

Vic_B As far as I know poodles are usually got used to the scene than to the rescue of somebody. People around don`t know how to use animals. Why dogs must be obligatorily used? I think it`s not in their nature to climb on the burrows, sniff the drugs` location and so on.It`s too dangerous for them. They are not hardy, strong and tough enough for such kind of work. I`ve got a poodle and I would never ever just think of such kind of nonsense. When I walk my dog I don`t lose sight of it because there are so many homeless big dogs which can easily attack my little darling. Small dogs are so unprotected and vulnerable. They shouldn`t be joined the police.

(corrected by Mariya_B)

Delya_C

I think that this is not suitable idea. To catch the criminals use big dogs, like Kommissar Rex. In addition, they take a big risk when they even spent time training exercises. I absolutely agree that we must use all possible ways to fight with crimes but this I think will not help because they are so small and cute dogs.

All it is certainly good but dogs of such small size cannot also is equivalent to help the person for example to pull out it from under a blockage as it will be made by a dog of larger size. Larger The dogs of larger sizes cannot always to reach the person through narrow cracks but they with rescue are helped by people, dogs can direct them and people simply to push aside obstacles. To my mind the dogs larger sizes more effectively than poodles or something like this one (Sanal_B)

= Mariya_B = I think that the idea is not brilliant. Such toy dogs are definitely not suitable for the police work. Even if they can be trained, they are not able to do hard work as big dogs can. Maybe police can use them for conspiracy because nobody will guess that cute little doggy is a specially-trained police worker. But still I think they will not be able to do even 10 % of bigger dogs’ job.

**Kermen_U**

Just imagine this situation: a tall, brutal policeman is going to the crime scene to catch the criminals with a dog that is usually ladies walk in the park with. I think this is ridiculous because people got used to watching policemen with big German Shepherds who can easily grab a human body out of the house ruins. And here we have a small, powerless puppy whom criminals can hurt or even kill. I believe that such kind of police dog is just a waste of time. Saglara_G

I don't think that it is a good idea to use small dogs in such position.

As we know, in most cases people are afraid of something big and

hardly will any offender feel fear of a small dog.

I cannot deny the fact that the small dog much quicker

but I doubt that these dogs are capable to find drugs,

or to attack the offender and deaktivate him,

may be only distract. Just imagine yourself the scene, in which

the poodle pursues the thief and when the dog catches up with him

what his further actions? To grasp the leg? Or to bark loudly??

(corrected by Mariya_B) || Certainly the big dogs can adapt to everything, but after all and small dos can perform work unfeasible to the big dogs. They can be not less useful the big dogs and deserve also
 * **ANSWER TO...** || **ANSWER TO...** ||
 * ==My answer to Delya_C==

(Viktoria_G)
Vic_B, I want to say that your image of the police dog is based on different films for children where big dog saves the world five times a day. And now you should understand that the small dog will go through small holes and will find the people who will still be alive, in case of the German Shepherds I don’t think they will squeeze even in a hole that will be three times larger that that in which poodle will squeeze.(Donir)

To Vic_B Vika, I partly agree with you, but… dogs are still dogs everywhere and everytime. It is in their nature to chase, to catch, to smell. It is just people, who forget about their primary function, trying to make some haircuts for dogs, putting on them different clothes. So the appearance doesn’t matter. These two poodles could be as dangerous as the big German Shepperd, in my opinion. (IKermenka)

Kermen_U

Don’t you understand that they will be used only during catastrophes and no one says that they will work with big policemen in the streets? (Donir)

Kermen_U I think that your opinion is too categorical. Why don’t you think that small-breed dogs can be also helpful? For instance, for big dogs it’s hard to reach those places, where small can easily get into there. And itcan help to many people! (Polina_E)

To Vic_B Aren't you sorry for those whom save these little rescuers? (Marina)

To Mariya_B
//I think that you underestimate small dogs. After all we didn't// //try to train at all small dogs, as for example German shepherds// //since a birth.// //And that if them to train and make a small dogs spies,// //and they can work in police.)))//

(Viktoria_G)
To Mariya_B I think they are being inside the hole, can easily make a little sap, due to this sap a victim could even move a bit. ( Marina)

To Sanal_B

I want to notice to you that I didn't say anything about that these cute poodles can grap a burglar or criminal, I just said that they can help with searchings, that's all :P (Marina)

To everybody who is against

Why does everyone think that police dogs should be big? I mean that everyone mention German Shepherds. For example, EMERCOM of Russia include into their work a small cocker-spaniels. Because they are very smart. (Marina)

to Kermen_U Who said that big dogs can't be hurt or even killed? From the point of view of common sense it is even more difficult to hit the smaller things, and in our case, dogs. The are more flexible, bright and faster, in my opinion. Respectfully yours, IKermenka :)

To Vic_B

Will people be punished someday or not, no one knows, but we are discussing is it a good idea to include such little breeds of dogs into police service. I don't see anything bad in this idea. They just help people in their hard work. And to my mind, people are not so terrible as you think. It's just my opinion. (Marina) || The respond to Donir How can they be helpful? Small dogs are small dogs. Of course, everybody is right when they say that small dogs can get into small gap, of the ruined house for example, but, would it manage to get out of it? This kind of dogs are not that strong as big ones. GelaGelka

Dasha_O Request (do not take it too serious) :))

Dasha. You are a cold-blooded and heartless person. Aren`t you sorry for them? What if one of these miraculous dear ones get hurt? Do you love animals? Vic_B

On the one hand I agree partly with Viktoria_G, but there were so many cases where big dogs adapt to all the terms of work.Delya_C

I disagreed with Marina’s opinion. That’s why her mind about this dog is mistakable. They cannot really to help the people like a German Shepherds. For example your cute poodles can’t catch the thief!!! And so cute dogs looking like a decoration with lady))) Sanal_B

To Donir Do you really think that such little creatures would be able to help somebody? Even if they can get through a small hole, they won’t grab a man out. Mariya_B

To Donir and Polina

Actually I understand that they will be used during catastrophes but is there any guarantee that these puppies will not stuck in the holes and so policemen will have to rescue them too?:D I believe that bigger dogs are much more helpful and they are able to save people's lives. (Kermen_U)

Reply to Kermen_U

OMG!!! May I ask you a question? HOW? How the big dog will go through the hole that is three times smaller? And the poodle will squeeze in. You think that if they will find people they will rescue them themselves? When they will find the people who are alive they will bark to the rescuers to give a signal that they found someone and they will be saved. (Donir)

To Victoria_G and Marina

I don’t underestimate small dogs, I love them! And as I already said I think they can work as spies or for conspiracy. But concerning hard police work, I mean chases, biting criminals, searching drugs, etc. they are useless.

Mariya_B

To everyone who is FOR!:)

Well I agree with you, guys, that poodles are small and clever but I believe that they are more vulnerable at the same time. I prefer bigger dogs, that’s my OPINION!:)

Kermen_U

To Marina

I don`t pity people the way I pity animals. We people destroy everything ourselves, around us with our own hands including these pair of unhappy poodles. Nobody cares about accidents the dogs might be involved, it`s very easy to change them another couple of poodles. It`s very pity we can`t treat the nature as we should and someday humanity will be punished deservedly. .

To Marina

Good for you!=) ||